If The Dunwitch Horror engendered any doubts about the trend of Lovecraft's horror fiction into a less-supernatural, more-science-fictionish direction, The Whisperer in Darkness put them definitively to rest. This deeply unsettling narrative blurs the line between and among weird fiction, dark fantasy, and science fiction, and arguably makes better use of its scholarly-but-a-little-thick professorial narrator to evoke sub-textual horror than any previous work. By the time he was writing this story, Lovecraft was acutely aware that he and his primary literary outlet - Weird Tales - were not exactly a match made in Valhalla. They had different literary goals in mind when approaching any given story. Weird Tales liked fairly, conventional shudder-pulp tales, especially ones that delivered a big finish; and Lovecraft had learned by experience that if he let his writing get too subtle and sophisticated, it would be, shot right back to him with an apologetic note from Farnsworth Wright. The Whisperer in Darkness may have been his attempt to bridge these two worlds. It features plenty of pulpy action, to the point of getting, roundly criticized by some Lovecraft fans for borrowing too much from writers like Robert E. Howard. And it does, have that oft-parodied "final crowning horror" line, the last piece of evidence withheld until the very last sentence that reveals The Horrid Truth; but it is voiced by Professor Wilmarth, and for a careful reader (who has, figured out the truth already, long since), it functions not so much, as a crowning horror, but as a line that rings true to a character, who we know really isn't as smart as he thinks he is.
